Meri's comment on Affirmative Action...
...was so valid, I decided to answer it in a blog-entry. Here the comment is, for those of you who haven't read it yet.
"Much as I can understand how you dislike affirmative action because of the personal impact it may have on you, how else do you think it should have been handled?Imagine if the mandates hadn't been made -- do you think the male- & white-dominated companies would EVER have chosen a black candidate over a white one? There are a lot of historical advantages that white people, in particular white Afrikaners have and have had for a helluva long time. Even as a white English-speaking girl growing up at the same time as you, Louis, it was pretty damn obvious that the language and gender discrimination was going to make getting a job difficult for me. Can you imagine how the black and coloured and asian kids we were at school with must have felt?"
And my answer: I was quite happy how they handled it, and I really do not want to complain too much about that. In hindsight I
can wonder if government incentives would not have worked better than passing laws, but that is hindsight. The companies probably would not have chosen black people to work for them then. But that brings me to the point now.
Affirmative action has been running for 12 years. And that's a long time. I have gone from being 11 years old to 23 years old. So I am just saying that the historical disadvantages that did exist, well, are probably always going to be there. The sad fact of the matter is that the majority of the poor in SA are black. Then again, they are just the majority, period. There now exists a big black middle class, growing every year, and there is also the ever-present black elite.
The black kids today have such better chance of getting education and jobs. This is a fact and will remain so - because of BEE, because of AA, and because of the politics of the whole thing. I am convinced, were they to scrap AA, this would remain so.
What worries me is that the black majority is not campaigning for the
end of Affirmative Action. They are quite happy to continue discriminating
ad infinitum against the white people. The ANC does not ask for the end of Affirmative Action. The struggling opposition party does not ask for the end - I am convinced out of fear for the backlash politically of appearing SO
evil as to ask for discrimination against
white people to stop. Not only that, there is no
TIME LIMIT for the duration of Affirmative Action. No "5 years from now we will end it", nothing. Which really really worries me. Will my kids one day have to sit with this same problem? What a nice incentive for me to stay in my own country, just to be discriminated against, and if I stay long enough, to have my kids discriminated against.
I have to wonder. Is it need that keeps it from ending, is it politics,
the bad sort, is it the fear of supporting white people in SA, or is it greed on the part of the masses. When will SA stop discriminating against ability? Because that is what it is when you reject able people in favour of better, more suitably coloured, people.